MT2002 Analysis

Previous page
(The epsilon-delta definition)
Contents Next page
(Metric spaces: definition and examples)

Some horrible functions

Here are a couple of the functions which originally forced mathematicians to refine their ideas of continuity.

  1. Let f be the function defined by f(x) = 1 if x is rational and f(x) = 0 if x is irrational.
    Then f is discontinuous at every point x.

    Proof
    Take p belongs Q and let (xn) be a sequence of irrationals converging to p. Then f(p) = 1 but f(xn)) rarrow 0 and so f is discontinuous at p.
    Similarly, if p notbelongs Q then choose a sequence of rationals converging to p and deduce the same result.

    An even cleverer (and more horrible) function is the following amazing example due to Dirichlet (1805 to 1859).

  2. Let f be the function defined by f(x) = 0 if x is irrational and f(x) = 1/b if x is the rational number a/b (in lowest terms).
    Then f is discontinuous at every rational point, but continuous at every irrational point.

    Proof
    Take p = a/b belongs Q and let (xn) be a sequence of irrationals converging to p. Then f(p) = 1/b noteq the limit of f(xn)).
    However, if p notbelongs Q then given epsilon > 0, we may find an interval around p which misses all the rationals of the form a/b with 1/b < epsilon. Then for sequences lying in this interval we do have (f(xn)) rarrow 0 = f(p) and so f is continuous at these points.



Previous page
(The epsilon-delta definition)
Contents Next page
(Metric spaces: definition and examples)

JOC September 2002