[GAP Forum] The equivalence of the two methods to create finitely presented groups based on the quotient of a free group.

Thomas Breuer sam at Math.RWTH-Aachen.De
Mon May 2 11:38:31 BST 2022


Dear Hongyi,

you wrote

> 1. I try to query the built-in help with the following command, but
> obtained so many entries I don't know how to choose from:
> 
> gap> ?Comm
>    Choose an entry to view, 'q' for none (or use ?<nr> later):
> 
>> │[1]   Guarana (not loaded): Comm
> 
>> │[2]   Utils: Comm
> 
>> │[3]   ANUPQ (not loaded): Commands from the Main p-Quotient menu
>                                                                 [...]

In this situation, the GAP help system uses a pager
that is apparently not as intuitive as it was intended.
One entry is selected,
you can move the selection up/down in the list of choices
via the up/down arrow keys,
and you can show the help for the selected entry by hitting the <Return> key.
Entering 'q' takes you back to the GAP prompt.

> 2. I also tried with the same method to check the following two commands:
> 
> gap> ?quit
> gap> ?QUIT
> 
> Gap gives exactly the same document for them:
> 
> > `quit'{quit}
>     This  closes  all  windows and just brings you back to the GAP
> window. In a new start of ITC all switches will be set to their
> default values.
>     The group that you had handled will still be available as a GAP object.

This is a bit surprising.
The text in question belongs to the help about 'quit'
from the GAP package ITC;
the list of choices should contain also entries for 'quit'
from the GAP Tutorial and for 'QUIT' from the Reference Manual.

All the best
Thomas




More information about the Forum mailing list